Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

But this isn't a small business loan: it's a debt to Amazon.


I read that as the business owner had a preexisting business loan with a personal guarantee.


Except the loan money will go straight to Amazon, and you are now unable to repay the loan to the bank


Where exactly does the bank enter the picture?

Scenario 1: Amazon will ask for the payment (if using cc); the bank will respond there are no funds in the account; Amazon deals directly with the company further directly, not with the bank, eventually getting payment order from the court. If the company went bankrupt meanwhile, Amazon might not get their money.

Scenario 2: Amazon will send the invoice; invoice will not get paid. After due date, Amazon will contact the company directly; bank doesn't even enter the picture, until collection order comes from the court. If the company went bankrupt meanwhile, Amazon might not get their money.

There's no scenario where some hypothetical loan would go straight to Amazon, unless Amazon has some instrument, that instruct the bank to pay them. Something like bank guarantee or promisory note, and uses them before declaring bankrupcy.


I think they were referring to a scenario where Amazon is draining the funds that have already been loaned. Thus Amazon already has their money, and the bank is the one coming after you during bankruptcy.


Not sure how it works in OP's country, but where I live, when you get a loan, you will get a new account. As you draw the loan, you are getting into negative balance; how far you can go is the limit of your loan. As you pay back the principal, you are getting back to zero balance.

So for Amazon draining loaned money, they would have to transfer them to a normal account and pay with debit card paired to that account, with no limit set.

It is not wise to transfer them to a normal account; you pay interest for the balance on the loan account; if you move them to your normal account, you are paying interest for money that is sitting on your normal account.


Wouldn't Amazon be draining a credit card directly? Tied to the account you received the loan on?


If they used CC (not debit), then any payment would mean creating a debt, so yes, they would have to pay to the bank. Because bank already paid in their name.

That's why you don't pay large sums with CC, but with invoice + bank transfer, and have a limit set on your cards, when you do.


Can you explain that more clearly? What is the reason to not pay large sums with a credit card?


Several factors:

- control: you are in control, when you do the payment. You can plan your cash flow.

- additional advantages: You also have payment terms, some vendors offer discounts for earlier payments; if your cash flow can handle that, why would you giving up of that?

- liability: with CC, you are getting credit that is drawn at other party leisure. It's you, who is liable for this credit line, even if the other party made a mistake. You are always liable to the bank, never towards the vendors. With bank transfers, every single payment was authorized by you (where by 'you' I mean authorized person at your company) and the liability is towards the vendor, who is not likely to have such a strong position (see Porter's five forces).

- leverage: if another party makes a mistake, they have motivation to correct it. Every company in existence has already received invoices, that are incorrect. Withholding payment until they are corrected is a strong motivator. Without that, you could be left without invoices that can be put into accounting AND without money that you have to account for.

- setting up processes: when you grow beyond certain size, you are going to want to formalize both the procurement, accounts payable and treasury. Having purchasing and payment discipline that are compatible with that already in place will mean less pain from the growth, less things to change.

When we need people in the field purchasing small supplies, we don't want them to handle cash, so they get debit (not credit) cards, with relatively small limits. It is enough for them to get by, but not enough to make any damage of significance. (The exception is fuel and that's what fuel cards are for - basically it has a form factor of a credit or debit card, but works only for fuel, is paired to a license plate and the vendor sends invoice at the end of the month).

Another scenario, where CCs are useful, if you need to pay something right now; you don't or can't want to wait for the order->delivery+invoice->payment cycle. That's fine for consumer impulse purchases, but that should not be a normal way for company purchases.

Of course, if you start a new business relation, some companies would not trust you, that you are going to pay the invoice; sending advance invoice and paying it is fine. In practice, it is quite rare occurrence.


Depends where Amazon ranks in seniority in bankruptcy (protection). You don't have to run out of money to file for it. Purdue Pharma sure didn't.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: