Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You are comparing the USA, a developed country, purely to developing countries. I mean, ya, the USA does better than much poorer countries, but can’t compare to any other developed ones. And just because all developed countries don’t have a unified homogenous homicide rate doesn’t really provide any excuse why America does so much more poorly.


I believe the problem with our developed country being compared to other developed countries goes beyond murder rate, wouldn't you agree?

We have less mobility and opportunity between the ranks of our society than some of these other countries.

That lack of equality makes our richest very well off, but our poorest live in literal third world conditions (as Alabama was designated two years ago.)

To be honest I don't see a problem with comparing us to both, but with the consideration that there is an awful lot of variance between the different subsections of our society.

What do you think?


> You are comparing the USA, a developed country, purely to developing countries. I mean, ya, the USA does better than much poorer countries, but can’t compare to any other developed ones.

Almost every country in the world is much poorer than the USA. Most European countries have a smaller per-capita GDP than Mississippi, the poorest US state.


Ya, that just makes the USA’s high homicide rate even more embarrassing.


Why? Money doesn’t magically solve all cultural problems.


Obviously, America is a case in point.


So you agree that social problems are independent of GDP and have no explanation for why you think America should be embarrassed? Seems like just baseless anti-Americanism.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: