Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> What the fuck happened to just TELLING THEM!?

People don't say anything. They use the software, and then when features are deprecated they come screaming for you to continue supporting it. It's a waste of resources if they have to create an 'RFC' for every time they want to deprecate a feature due to development workload, when they could just have it report usage of features within the app. It's literally just how many people use specific features in the code they're writing; they're not watching what you type, they're not uploading a log of window titles like early blizzard anticheat software[0]. If you don't want them to be able to make informed decisions about the software they write you shouldn't use it, just create your own and send out a yearly/quarterly survey asking people to tell you what features they use, and see just how many people respond (hint: 30% of users is an unlikely best case scenario for external surveys[1]); hopefully that sample is good enough to drive decision on what features you stop supporting and what features to focus on.

0: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2005/10/new-gaming-feature-spy...

1: https://peoplepulse.com/resources/useful-articles/survey-res....



> It's literally just how many people use specific features in the code they're writing; they're not watching what you type, they're not uploading a log of window titles like early blizzard anticheat software[0].

The problem is that, if it's not that now, it will, or at least might, be that eventually. It's a lot easier to make sure that an app isn't phoning home at all, than that it's phoning home with only approved information.

For example, it's a huge problem with browser extensions that, even if they start off well designed to respect a user's privacy and to gather information only in ways that are essential to their function, and that even if the original developer remains true to that mission, still if the extension becomes popular the developer will be prey to a lot of pressure from bad actors who want to buy the rights to the extension precisely so that they can expand the data-gathering into the realm that you implicitly acknowledge is unacceptable.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: