Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This film gets bashed often but I remember seeing it in the cinema when it was released and I absolutely adored it, and still do. I’ve ’inflicted’ it on several friends and acquaintances — and keep in mind I’m no M. Night Shyamalan fan having never seen Unbrekable and having walked out of the cinema midway through The Last Airbender that I hold to be one of the worst films ever. Anyway back to The Village: its scenery and ambiance were absolutely perfect. The twist was pure genius.


It's one of my favorite movies. I love movies or books that get me thinking "what the hell is going on" until in the end there's a twist where it now all makes sense.

Another movie like this is "Big Fish"


There wasn't a twist in Big Fish.


I remember liking it a lot, I didn't see the twist coming even though the guy was known at the time for having a twist in his films. I liked how it wasn't just about a "gotcha" but revealed character motivations and how people try to retreat from the world due to trauma, and the lengths parents go to protect their children. I bet it would hit harder if I watched it now that I have children.


IDC about the twist. It's a standout to me on VIBE. Of what I've seen from MNS, it's my favorite.


The slo mo shot still gives me chills.


The film didn't work for me, because I didn't realise the "twist" was supposed to be a twist. I had assumed it from the start and was expecting the reverse to be the twist.


As somebody who did like the movie despite itself, I like the version you expected more


Same. “Oh, it’s just… the obvious thing.”




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: