Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You make a good point. I have watched several Hancock shows, including the one on Netflix, and while some of his points seem plausible, he tries to link everything into a common source that does not seem plausible to me.

There are some things that are plausible that I think would be interesting to see actual academics researchers spend time on, such as the Sphinx and a few other claims.

- The Sphinx:

To me it seems plausible that the Sphinx may have been constructed before the Egyption civilization, based on geological analysis that indicates a wetter climate and that the head seems to be carved much later than the rest (even proportions are wrong).

The findings in Göbleki Tepe proves that you don't need a massive agricultural civilization to create impressive stone works. People can get together and make amazing things without having to invent an Atlantian civilization that travels the world.

Unfortunately I think that Hancocks involvement may prevent serious research into this, as they don't want to be associated with him.



> The findings in Göbleki Tepe proves that you don't need a massive agricultural civilization to create impressive stone works.

Is this definitive? Couldn’t it be evidence that the people that built it might have had massive agriculture that we haven’t found yet?


They haven't found anything that would require an agricultural society to support it. Also, the time and location matches the origin of the oldest known strains of farmed grain. And the remains of people from agricultural societies differs dramatically from non-agricultural, again not far away in time and space from Gobleki Tepe. And the amount and type of animal remains suggests non-agricultural diet, with animals hunted and slaughtered elsewhere and carried in (the site wasn't used year round). So dawn of agriculture. A popular theory is this sort of society grew big enough (due to abundance of animals in the region at that time) that they needed to start farming for non-essentials, such as grain for alcohol, kicking off what would become agricultural societies.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: