Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Sooooo, do those of us that bought into it get compensated for the misrepresentation? I doubt it but that’s be sensible.


What is the average lifespan of a car? If the service is not delivered during the useful life of the vehicle I would assume it already qualifies as misrepresentation. 2016 is 8 years ago, I am sure plenty of those vehicles have put over 150k miles on them and have deprecated into nothing.


It's 150k acceptable today? I was upset when my transmission went out at 200k.

Maybe I'm wrong but I think the expected life of a car is quite a bit longer than that?


I feel like with the warranty usually lasting 50k or so, it’s reasonable to say many people wouldn’t keep a car, or have ever planned to, past 150k, even if the car is perfectly drivable 8 years on with that mileage.

My car is that old, and I expect to keep it at least 8 more. But many would have traded in by 8 years especially if they drive so much more than me.


Some states/countries publish stats on car registrations/unregistrations and also record mileage each year at annual tests.

I'm pretty sure somewhere on the internet you'll find enough official data to figure out median car mileage.


Well after looking, there aren't any good reliable sources for an easy number. But comparing what state data I could find, it seems like 12 years and 200k mileage is the median.

So I maintain my original statement. 8 years and 150k miles for a car that is sold as a simpler (mechanically) and more reliable because of that mechanical simplicity is kind of crappy.


As is usual in these type of class actions, you’ll probably get coupon for 10% off the heated seat upgrades in a new Tesla after 10 years of litigation.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: